本文轉貼自PTT
台灣最大的本土社群網站
分享這篇文章到Facebook、Google+或噗浪！


 作者  junichialexx (EJXU)                                    看板  Gossiping 
 標題  Re: [新聞] ５款鮮乳評比 義美 福樂最營養                                
 時間  Tue Jul 30 23:45:31 2013                                               
───────────────────────────────────────

這裡有真的"巷子內"的介紹，請大家參考看看。

http://www.cool3c.com/article/69959

小弟不才也是這裡面某家食品廠的員工(光泉)，
這件事情很想跳出來替公司講話－

台灣不是只有一家食品良心企業

就這篇來看這整個評比就拿錯東西來比，
義美、福樂這兩家拿的產品都是掛＂牛乳＂兩字，
跟鮮奶有本質上的不同，鮮奶是不可添加生乳內含之外的添加物，
而若是純比較鮮乳之間的排行（有小牛標章的），
那市售鮮乳之中又有分為＂強化鮮乳＂跟＂無調整鮮乳＂，
如果要拿強化鮮乳來比的話，光泉應該是拿＂乳香世家鮮乳＂來比，
而不是拿＂光泉鮮乳＂這成分無調整的來做比較。

小弟本人就是生產線的人員，這不知道有沒有卦？
我們家的無調整鮮奶真的就是沒添加任何東西，
從酪農奶車載送到廠內，經管路殺菌直到包裝充填，
沒有任何的添加行為，所以我們敢稱作成分無調整。

你問我們家的鮮奶怎麼那麼稀？鮮奶最初本來就是這樣子的口感。
你鮮奶加東加西的，說好聽是增加營養成份，但這些東西好不好，
真的好嗎？是消費者要的嗎？我不知道...

光泉大園廠　製造課　李嘉祥

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 36.231.194.124
→ ur260:你不推光泉 要收到資遣信了                                 07/30 23:46
推 MaYingDog:標準化                                                07/30 23:46
推 THH:我喝過剛從牧場出來的，明明就很香很濃                        07/30 23:46
推 falcon11:小時候喝不少光泉 不錯阿                                07/30 23:46
推 DASHOCK:光泉的也算便宜拉                                        07/30 23:47
推 Kay731:我都喝光泉耶~ 給你個推~                                  07/30 23:47
→ DASHOCK:調味乳都喝光泉跟國農@@                                  07/30 23:47
推 qsc753:報上名擔保 給推                                          07/30 23:47
→ Kay731:光泉麥芽有夠好喝~                                        07/30 23:47
推 adi5566:乳香好喝                                                07/30 23:47
推 seemoon2000:我以前都喝統一的牛奶 現在基本只喝光泉的= =          07/30 23:47
→ kondoyu:敢具名就是真男人 比道歉不敢寫真名的廢物強多了           07/30 23:47
推 Ratalie:光泉好喝 推                                             07/30 23:48
→ cloud7515:是高溫殺菌所以喝起來淡淡的 低溫殺菌才會比較保持原味   07/30 23:48
推 rererere147:具名給推                                            07/30 23:48
推 fenix220:推良心公司                                             07/30 23:48
推 akirakid:我都喝光泉                                             07/30 23:48
推 xul4m4vu6666:我都喝光泉  福樂稠得很噁心                         07/30 23:48
→ chadhappy200:想想應該也是，牛奶大部分組成是水，口感應該偏稀的   07/30 23:48
→ DASHOCK:不過牛奶這十年來   真的漲太多了>"<                      07/30 23:48
推 HermesKing:光泉的成分也很單純喔（我是說豆漿）                   07/30 23:48
推 alcloth:你現在不是住台中嗎？ 怎麼會在大園場？                   07/30 23:48
推 Narusawayui:這要推一下 解釋的很好                               07/30 23:48
→ lin2000086:美國都稀的                                           07/30 23:48
推 leocean:推                                                      07/30 23:48
→ abc06:光泉跟義美都很好喝 福樂也不錯                             07/30 23:48
推 yayahong:推!                                                    07/30 23:49
推 hhtj:                                                           07/30 23:49
→ ppc:我喝中興大學的牛奶也淡淡的 但好喝                           07/30 23:49
推 frostmourne:                                                    07/30 23:49
→ basketkdash:牧場剛擠出來的會香濃那是因為沒分離過一半都乳脂...   07/30 23:49
→ alcloth:為何我喝牧場現擠的都很稀？ 上面卻有人說很濃？           07/30 23:49
推 jo0214:雖然家裡習慣訂初鹿，不過奶茶、打果汁還是加光泉好喝~!!!   07/30 23:49
推 piggii:我都喝光泉                                               07/30 23:49
推 Homepage:光泉比統一好                                           07/30 23:50
→ NEWOLD:為什麼林鳳營算鮮乳                                       07/30 23:50
推 dick18:                                                         07/30 23:50
→ miacp:奶油都被抽走了吧                                          07/30 23:50
推 yanli2:只喝光泉！                                               07/30 23:50
→ abc06:光泉 義美是我目前喝過最好的兩間                           07/30 23:50
推 patato2:吃牧草的會比較稀...吧?                                  07/30 23:50
推 amig0123:推                                                     07/30 23:50
推 AAQQUUAA:牧場應該稀稀的 乳化漂亮的液體 其實不濃 不黏膩          07/30 23:50
推 facefear:推 光泉的好喝!!!!!!!!!!!!!                             07/30 23:51
推 edwardazaz:下次試試                                             07/30 23:51
推 dogface:明天買杯有巧克力脆片的來喝                              07/30 23:51
推 whatc21:推光泉 我喜歡喝稀的  討厭太濃很假                       07/30 23:51
推 allure1:喝過中興的   水水的鮮奶才是真奶  滿街都是假奶           07/30 23:51
→ AAQQUUAA:加了鹿角膠 會有一種很黏很噁心的口感                    07/30 23:51
推 matrix4096:具名給推                                             07/30 23:52
推 Henrique:推!                                                    07/30 23:52
→ davidou:你敢具名 我就敢推拉           ㄟ靠 推用掉了 樓下幫我補  07/30 23:52
推 trij:具名給推                                                   07/30 23:52
推 kleinregen:光泉鮮乳最近大缺貨  一天跑兩家超市都買不到 WHY??     07/30 23:52
推 dnzteeqrq:光泉豆漿好喝XDDD                                      07/30 23:52
推 wincecarter:推祥哥!!!!!!!!!!!1                                  07/30 23:52
推 cheko:要來怒買光泉惹                                            07/30 23:52
推 cutebabylin:推!!                                                07/30 23:52
推 greedypeople:假如真的都沒調整感覺還不錯                         07/30 23:53
推 winered:今天剛買了一大瓶三公升的光泉 就是看中它敢標100%生乳     07/30 23:53
推 bjj:掛名推                                                      07/30 23:53
推 AK00627:                                                        07/30 23:53
推 inshadow:敢具名,可信度就大幅提升                                07/30 23:53
推 dir2007:推                                                      07/30 23:53
推 immoi:只喝光泉+義美啊...好像是從王建民代言開始的習慣..(好久了)  07/30 23:53
推 jasonmoon:敢具名,屌                                             07/30 23:53
推 s302520:推!!!!鄉民楷模!!!                                       07/30 23:53
推 pei5444:推  喝光泉長大的                                        07/30 23:53
→ takechance: 光泉鮮奶味道跟我小時候喝有變，這怎麼一回事?         07/30 23:53
推 lacclwu:推                                                      07/30 23:53
→ greedypeople:我之前都喝林鳳營低脂這樣……                       07/30 23:53
推 ezbird:林鳳X只是加寡糖而已  不知道出名什小                      07/30 23:54
推 playerj:從小就喝光泉 :>                                         07/30 23:54
推 Roudy:推                                                        07/30 23:54
推 vksloppy:剛榨的牛乳一點都不稀~有點太濃烈，鮮乳真的沒加水？      07/30 23:54
→ takechance: 我從小喝光泉長大的，但幾年前鮮奶味道有變            07/30 23:54
推 june0204:推~看到最營養,應該加不少東西吧XDDDDDD                  07/30 23:54
→ greedypeople:以後可能會一半一半吧                               07/30 23:54
推 arianis:有署名，推                                              07/30 23:54
推 chengweirh:哇 具名欸 真男人                                     07/30 23:54
→ ezbird:飲料店都拿林鳳營來作廣告  又沒有比較好喝 真是迷失        07/30 23:54
推 tankcase:推光泉, 實習的時候就知道完全"無添加"就真的是"無添加"   07/30 23:55
推 mark31326:喝過現場的 稀稀的                                     07/30 23:55
推 iamotaku:好膽，推                                               07/30 23:55
→ DASHOCK:林鳳營很濃郁阿....                                      07/30 23:55
噓 yrrh:最近看它的飲料有加修飾澱粉，感覺有統一化的趨勢             07/30 23:56
推 headcase:推一個!                                                07/30 23:56
推 GADFATHER:推光泉  親戚在裡面做也是這樣跟我說的                  07/30 23:56
推 gold97972000:認真給推!                                          07/30 23:56
推 shyyo7589:可是  光泉真的很稀....                                07/30 23:56
推 sunmoon1010:具名推                                              07/30 23:56
推 tsukikaede:平常都喝光泉給推                                     07/30 23:56
推 whalecell:具名 真男人!                                          07/30 23:56
→ GADFATHER:他說加最多料的就是林X營和統2的                        07/30 23:56
推 MSilence:推 乳香世家好喝                                        07/30 23:57
→ wht810090:給原po，台灣的乳品與飲品大概只剩下貴公司與義美還值得  07/30 23:57
→ hump:我也蠻喜歡光泉的                                           07/30 23:57
推 ch110:新出的豆漿也好喝!                                         07/30 23:57
推 cosicosi:超喜歡光泉的口感 從小喝到大                            07/30 23:57
推 kshtainan:                                                      07/30 23:57
推 mina:推光泉，我有個食品界的朋友很推你們，所以我很常買           07/30 23:57
推 m99:                                                            07/30 23:57
推 FCKDIY:推光泉~                                                  07/30 23:57
→ wht810090:信賴...想請問一下原po有沒有以下幾件事的八卦：1.杏仁   07/30 23:57
推 ViewMoon:具名推                                                 07/30 23:58
推 yu0308:推 都喝光泉                                              07/30 23:58
推 ck517:光泉的推                                                  07/30 23:58
推 viro72:敢具名 真男人                                            07/30 23:58
推 ian90911:推                                                     07/30 23:58
推 mutkan:推~                                                      07/30 23:59
→ wht810090:牛奶為何會停產T_T 2.富維他等系列調味奶的改版史        07/30 23:59
推 gold97972000:明天就買光泉                                       07/30 23:59
→ winiS:鮮乳光泉還是最好買 義美完全沒看過orz                      07/30 23:59
推 nojoewu:光泉推，從小喝~                                         07/30 23:59
推 yuee:推光泉,從小喝到大                                          07/30 23:59
→ loveswazi:不給推 因為你無法確認酪農有沒有加東西...              07/30 23:59
推 abc06:文中 那個義美鮮乳 有寫100％生乳的 好喝 推一下             07/31 00:00
→ abc06:不過目前只有在門市看過                                    07/31 00:00
推 dtdon1699:推光泉                                                07/31 00:00
推 xomega:光泉真的讚                                               07/31 00:00
→ kzzoz80:我也選光泉                                              07/31 00:01
推 lovejamwu:看這篇.我以後會買光泉了.感謝.                         07/31 00:02
推 clickslither:看到這篇馬上出門買瓶無調整鮮乳                     07/31 00:02
推 LOVEMONKEY:敢寫名負責  推!!!                                    07/31 00:02
推 henrydai:我只有喝光泉的不會拉.....連義美的都會= =               07/31 00:02
推 j20006640:推                                                    07/31 00:02
推 akway:推                                                        07/31 00:02
推 HORNER:推屬名!                                                  07/31 00:03
推 maxlovesviva:推, 不過要比較應該拿義美的"鮮乳'來比較吧           07/31 00:03
推 a5512090:敢寫名字就給推！！                                     07/31 00:03
→ maxlovesviva:義美一樣有鮮乳跟牛乳.拿你們家鮮乳打義美牛乳不公平  07/31 00:03
推 BelkanWar:說實話，給推!!                                        07/31 00:04
推 pida:明天怒買                                                   07/31 00:04
→ maxlovesviva:義美的鮮乳喝起來也不會特別濃 但就是真的很香        07/31 00:04
推 fantasibear:推                                                  07/31 00:04
推 jack7217:反觀桶二....爛到底                                     07/31 00:04
→ maxlovesviva:光泉鮮乳也很好喝, 至少喝起來比統一個放心多了       07/31 00:05
推 Oxhorn:挖賽  打名字掛保證!                                      07/31 00:05
推 wht810090:應該是要抓同量級的產品來比較才對+1 義美鮮乳真的不太   07/31 00:05
→ ayler88:光泉讚啦!                                               07/31 00:05
推 ezbird:請問原PO 說冬天乳源少 夏天太熱牛又不爽  牛到底想怎樣     07/31 00:05
推 hunk124:以前的光泉鮮乳是不是保麗龍的包裝 像個D字型的外觀?       07/31 00:05
推 tcpic:怒買三罐                                                  07/31 00:05
推 micotosai:我只喝光泉跟義美這兩家味道很近，只是義美的味道是光泉  07/31 00:05
→ wht810090:常見，義美的直營門市又不夠多- -                       07/31 00:05
推 collen66:具名推~                                                07/31 00:05
推 gomenba:具名負責給推                                            07/31 00:05
推 MuseLand:很難買 去全聯都買不到QQ                                07/31 00:05
→ micotosai:義美是光泉牛奶的加強版                                07/31 00:05
→ Tenging:光泉呢?                                                 07/31 00:06
推 tpkgo:光泉是統一的 不怕加料嗎                                   07/31 00:06
推 sobigbird:我都只買光泉跟義美 讚啦 冰箱就有一罐                  07/31 00:06
推 fishead1116:那初鹿的有另外加料嗎                                07/31 00:06
推 colatea:義美鮮乳不錯 但家庭號真的很難買 進貨量好少              07/31 00:06
推 supernick:從小就只買光泉推!                                     07/31 00:06
→ perlone:只要是良心食品 都支持啦                                 07/31 00:06
推 HAHADEAD:蠻有意義的 推!                                         07/31 00:07
→ micotosai:光泉沒有統一鮮乳那種怪味                              07/31 00:07
推 ie0e84:具名推                                                   07/31 00:07
噓 hyscout:義美也是100%生乳 http://ppt.cc/NMcs 待會兒補推          07/31 00:07
推 mingc43:我家從小到大都只買光泉!!超好喝，其他都不好喝            07/31 00:07
推 p3962260:敢具名給推!! 我也愛光泉牛奶                            07/31 00:07
推 abc06:光泉 義美 福樂 三選一  義美前天才喝 稀稀的超香 門市限定   07/31 00:07
推 Yolosnow:光泉不錯                                               07/31 00:07
推 wht810090:光泉只是部份股份由統一集團持股，沒連經營權也讓給統一  07/31 00:07
推 newstarisme:不要買統一的就好                                    07/31 00:07
→ eva19452002:怒喝光泉鮮乳                                        07/31 00:08
推 Spade:光泉巧克力牛奶好喝                                        07/31 00:08
推 pttverygood:署名負責~這篇我信了 光泉不錯                        07/31 00:08
※ hatako:轉錄至某隱形看板                                         07/31 00:08
→ fegat:我之前都喝光泉 現在喝福樂一番鮮 不錯喝 還便宜幾塊         07/31 00:09
推 hyscout:補推                                                    07/31 00:09
→ shinny1206:喜歡福樂                                             07/31 00:09
推 ht6401:光泉好喝 另外具名推!!                                    07/31 00:09
推 ioz:勇者!給推!!                                                 07/31 00:09
推 bowei99:報名字給推                                              07/31 00:09
推 cccandice:其實光泉比較好喝                                      07/31 00:09
→ jghs121:屬名推                                                  07/31 00:09
推 rinsoukan:喜歡喝光泉的調味乳~                                   07/31 00:09
推 potwo:推一下..我也都喝光泉..                                    07/31 00:09
推 ken90007:我老爸獸醫專門跑動物防治所和畜牧場的                   07/31 00:10
推 Tatsuba:具名給推！                                              07/31 00:10
→ wht810090:這一二十年來光泉有不少口味還不錯的調味牛奶沒能繼續量  07/31 00:10
推 aizawafff: !                                                    07/31 00:10
→ ken90007:都叫我們自己家人買光泉鮮奶                             07/31 00:10
→ wht810090:產下去，例如與初代富維他同期、500cc綠色紙盒裝的燕麥   07/31 00:10
推 thisbook:推具名                                                 07/31 00:11
→ wht810090:牛奶，還有一度重出江湖(但配方似乎與早期型有差一些)的  07/31 00:11
推 murray5566:我都喝光泉 爽                                        07/31 00:11
→ uice:現在買豆漿鮮乳﹐我都買義美光泉﹐目前這二家讓我感覺有良心   07/31 00:11
推 greymon62:有空我試試光泉  我目前喝過最像現榨未加工的是初鹿的    07/31 00:11
推 XBUCKXMR:那英泉如何？                                           07/31 00:11
→ wht810090:、最後仍然在市面上消失的杏仁牛奶，真的很可惜...       07/31 00:11
推 p3962260:富維他跟果汁口味超好喝的阿!!!!                         07/31 00:11
→ murray5566:一堆人看到假前就說林鳳營 香醇濃 都是木舌             07/31 00:12
推 sevenath:頂好有進義美鮮奶，但買不買得到要碰運氣                 07/31 00:12
→ wht810090:然後高鈣強化+甜口味的高鈣牛奶也在最新的一次大改版後   07/31 00:12
推 kula77:敢具名，推你                                             07/31 00:13
推 Zodiac10:show名字給推！                                         07/31 00:13
→ wht810090:也終於消失了，這款最早也是跟初代富維他同期的          07/31 00:13
推 ggggg:推光泉 去參觀過工廠!!很乾淨                               07/31 00:13
推 jokker:光泉不錯                                                 07/31 00:14
推 guest0926:我也都只喝光泉&義美                                   07/31 00:14
推 rosana:我自己的親人也曾在光泉廠工作過，親人表示和原PO所說相同   07/31 00:15
推 ltameion:                                                       07/31 00:15
推 ff181:果汁牛乳~~~                                               07/31 00:15
推 phix:可能酪農在去之前就稀釋了....:P                             07/31 00:15
推 MimI2008:不會先去牧場買鮮奶 在喝 光泉 是不是一樣所謂的稀        07/31 00:15
推 rollingliz:麥芽奶大推!!                                         07/31 00:15
→ wht810090:統整之後最新的系列名好像改叫「健益多」機能強化牛乳    07/31 00:16
→ hemble:帥氣 直接掛名字!!                                        07/31 00:16
推 sakyer:掛名男子漢                                               07/31 00:16
推 tenchi01:牛奶我還是喜歡光泉，推推                               07/31 00:16
推 chemiblue:怒推光泉 想當年支持俊國熊也喜歡光泉的產品..XDD        07/31 00:16
推 madcloud:敢具名，給推!                                          07/31 00:16
→ wht810090:連富維他牛乳也被統整到這系列名下去了                  07/31 00:16
推 YU3310:猛                                                       07/31 00:17
推 kyona:從小就喝光泉！                                            07/31 00:17
推 DarkSp:明天喝光泉!!給你肯定!!                                   07/31 00:17
→ whichway:光泉員工可以用優惠價格買到的自己鮮奶，但是少數人拿去   07/31 00:18
推 yaya:讚                                                         07/31 00:18
推 sadwater:光泉比較好!!學校營養師都推光泉                         07/31 00:18
→ whichway:轉賣大園、草漯......等的飲料店，雖然有限制員工購買數   07/31 00:19
→ momoisacow:可是我小時候喝的 光泉很好喝 約莫8年前開始 就變稀了   07/31 00:19
推 domago:優文                                                     07/31 00:19
推 a84885640:都喝林鳳營                                            07/31 00:19
推 Syffence:給推                                                   07/31 00:19
推 wht810090:頂好連義美的各種豆奶都要碰運氣- -                     07/31 00:19
推 chung74511:光泉不錯喝阿~                                        07/31 00:19
推 leilyudi:推 光泉便宜! 用鮮奶茶也比較好喝~                       07/31 00:19
→ whichway:量......反正，公司給的福利阿~                          07/31 00:19
→ abc06:跳過統一就對了                                            07/31 00:20
推 edison321:真男人推!!!                                           07/31 00:20
推 mycoeba:推 我也是都喝你們家的                                   07/31 00:20
推 rickb9l:真男人   敢具名就值得推了                               07/31 00:20
推 kaede1412:掛名 給推                                             07/31 00:21
→ Puser:牛奶只喝光泉 覺得只有它好喝 但泡奶綠用林鳳營較香濃        07/31 00:21
推 diviner:下次會買光泉的來喝 感謝推薦                             07/31 00:21
推 oticed:只喝林鳳營或光泉!!!                                      07/31 00:22
→ TSbb:林鳳營可以跟光泉或義美比了，本日最就可。                   07/31 00:23
推 asdghjk789:推光泉   我只喝光泉跟福樂的                          07/31 00:24
推 Fiendyux:覺得乳香世家.義美.柳營都很好喝啊!                      07/31 00:24
推 tensinya:光泉有茉莉蜜 敲擊好喝~~~~~~~~~                         07/31 00:25
推 Norther:初鹿or台大or光泉or義美>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>林ＸＸ  07/31 00:25
推 xu42j0:光泉良心企業阿 我也會買 還有義美等牌輪流喝 可是不買統一  07/31 00:26
推 tran628:推光泉!                                                 07/31 00:27

----本文使用PCMAN+BBI轉貼----


※ 新版PCMAN開放測試中，新增功能：    



用PCMAN+BBI連回PTT原文