本文轉貼自PTT
台灣最大的本土社群網站
分享這篇文章到Facebook、Google+或噗浪！


 作者  hamphry (.....)                                        看板  Gossiping 
 標題  [問卦] 重課"單身稅"解決少子化的八卦??                                  
 時間  Thu Sep 26 13:16:43 2013                                               
───────────────────────────────────────

饅頭板有板友提到 重課單身稅 解決少子化的問題...

我覺得這樣的構想非常好...

單身者的綜合所得稅30% 結婚之後降為15% 生一個小孩再扣3% 最低稅率6%...

這樣就能確保每對夫婦至少都生3個小孩...

這位板友還提到...

有研究指出 台灣少子化的問題 不在 "結了婚不敢生" 而在 "根本不結婚"...

所以要解決台灣少子化問題 首重提高"結婚率"...

要提高結婚率 重課單身稅 是政府可以努力的目標...

大家覺得 有掛嗎??

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 163.32.224.205
噓 kent:你會被甲甲噓                                               09/26 13:17
推 malediction:怎麼課都比結婚便宜                                  09/26 13:17
→ dyspnea:1F.....                                                 09/26 13:17
噓 ls4860:你到底有沒有好好用腦想過?                                09/26 13:17
推 obov:日行一善你會被甲甲噓補                                     09/26 13:17
→ iqeyuuri:這麼馬英九的構想你也敢講                               09/26 13:17
噓 kil1ua:一堆領22k的 你還課單身稅???????????????                  09/26 13:17
反正22K的魯蛇 扣掉 免稅額 跟 扣除額 之後 也沒多少肉可以課...
課單身稅 重傷的是那些高薪的單身貴族...
→ sagarain:薪水沒有10萬的都不准上網 如何                          09/26 13:17
→ smalltwo:那表示你必須大學就結婚,免得你一出社會就被扣30%         09/26 13:17
大學剛畢業 約22歲 青春的肉體 非常很適合結婚懷孕...
噓 StarTouching:先重課房屋稅 人人有房 結婚生子就容易了             09/26 13:17
※ 編輯: hamphry         來自: 163.32.224.205       (09/26 13:21)
→ ji394xu3:超惷的                                                 09/26 13:17
推 alen831013:1f趁亂出櫃                                           09/26 13:17
→ Smilingface:你結婚養小孩了嗎?                                   09/26 13:18
噓 uisnegr:什麼爛方法                                              09/26 13:18
推 jopyt:沒錢怎麼結婚，生一大堆小孩沒錢養都丟給政府嗎?             09/26 13:18
噓 mykuririn:塊陶阿                                                09/26 13:18
→ kairi5217:嗯嗯 有結婚但生不出孩子的 也要重課稅 可以解決孤兒的   09/26 13:18
政府可以補助結婚生不出孩子的 做試管嬰兒 由政府全額補助...
→ plum306:這想法滿棒的  這種違憲的法條也只有馬政府敢作            09/26 13:18
噓 EqualMan:違憲？                                                 09/26 13:18
噓 mylo:泥聽過甲結婚 喔 不 是假結婚ㄇ                              09/26 13:18
→ kairi5217:問題 這樣好噗好?                                      09/26 13:18
→ tonyy801101:真要課那我自殺算了 一工作就繳這種鳥稅               09/26 13:18
→ kil1ua:22K直接打七折 單身的 一個月實拿15400 = =                 09/26 13:18
→ BRANFORD:領失業救濟金的  要定期向主管機關回報自己有在努力找     09/26 13:18
→ hsunting2000:都22K了還要課多重?                                 09/26 13:18
推 lk011382:YA  我不是甲甲                                         09/26 13:18
→ ji394xu3:我只知道這種蠢政策會有一堆人去假結婚再離婚 XD          09/26 13:18
噓 nicejelly:生了怎麼養？節下來的稅金夠養小孩？                    09/26 13:18
→ hipab:那不都不能離婚？ 大家偷吃 吃爽爽？                        09/26 13:19
噓 turgnev:重課廢文稅比較有用                                      09/26 13:19
→ FallRed:八卦板要滅板了我看                                      09/26 13:19
噓 Bean0918:剛剛才在那版看到這文章 我只能說事情沒你想的這麼簡單    09/26 13:19
→ BRANFORD:單身稅難道不該這樣  舉得出證明有在努力找的  怎麼可以   09/26 13:19
→ BRANFORD:抽                                                     09/26 13:19
→ HarryHTC:讚成啊~~~                                              09/26 13:19
噓 dacapo:廢文 罰很重的話 隨便找個找不到伴的假結婚就好了           09/26 13:20
噓 rexlin:歧視單身，那要不要乾脆男女生強制交配算了                 09/26 13:21
噓 chenyeart:我以外貌主義之名拒繳!!                                09/26 13:21
噓 mykuririn:假結婚 真節稅                                         09/26 13:21
※ 編輯: hamphry         來自: 163.32.224.205       (09/26 13:23)
噓 ji394xu3:全台灣禁賣保險套禁作人工結紮手術 我看還比較實際 XD     09/26 13:21
噓 l835566:沒錢結婚的不就更慘                                      09/26 13:21
噓 SuperUp:要解決財政問題先把官員亂花預算的腦袋改造一下吧          09/26 13:21
→ avgirl:不想繳稅就會有強迫女人做老婆的事情發生了~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  09/26 13:22
→ ji394xu3:順便要求每年都要參加"男女雜交營"~~~種男與種女交配      09/26 13:22
噓 HuaLan:政府有種讓每人年薪百萬元以上再來討論單身稅的問題         09/26 13:22
噓 killingni:建議生5個才能考高普考                                 09/26 13:22
噓 toya123:                                                        09/26 13:23
噓 pupuputtt:生了小孩卻養不起然後全家燒炭這樣有比較好嗎?           09/26 13:23
※ 編輯: hamphry         來自: 163.32.224.205       (09/26 13:24)
→ ogcman:你在反串嗎... 你會認同這種想法 我覺得非常神奇            09/26 13:23
噓 BRANFORD:重罰自殺 抽自殺稅                                      09/26 13:24
→ jenchieh5:養不起孩子  寧可單身也不要日後變人間悲劇              09/26 13:24
噓 iamalam2005:                                                    09/26 13:24
噓 sunlucky:我是覺得不要課稅啦  就35以上沒結婚的就強制配對就好啦   09/26 13:24
→ pupuputtt:如果台灣真要這樣搞就是燒炭死我也不想這繳懲罰單身的稅  09/26 13:24
→ cloudwolf:笨蛋才提這政策~~~                                     09/26 13:24
→ BRANFORD:統一教表示                                             09/26 13:24
噓 gotohikaru:開放蘿莉啊幹                                         09/26 13:24
噓 ji394xu3:晚上7點以後全台灣戒嚴不準看電視 不準出門 沒事都去作愛  09/26 13:25
噓 elle:可以為了錢結婚 那還需要愛嗎                                09/26 13:25
→ ogcman:看來你不知道台灣離婚率有40% 如果用逼婚的 大概上看60%     09/26 13:25
噓 linyap:這啥天才邏輯 你活在人間嗎?                               09/26 13:25
→ smalltwo:那就問你個最簡單的~~你為什麼還沒結婚~~政府克你重稅你   09/26 13:26
噓 cospergod:找不到的你要幫她們介紹？                              09/26 13:26
推 turbomons:順便加 傷殘稅 老不死稅 甲甲稅 南蠻稅 吱吱稅 國力UP    09/26 13:26
噓 chungyiju:                                                      09/26 13:26
→ ogcman:你知道離婚率高 帶來的負面效應 比少子化嚴重嗎             09/26 13:26
→ aulaulrul4:等哪天台灣出了希特勒大概就可能做到....               09/26 13:26
→ smalltwo:就能找到一個女人or男人嫁你娶妳嗎??                     09/26 13:26
噓 kurtsgm:課三小啦                                                09/26 13:26
噓 vivawei:整天笑水母 沒想到還有人比水母還腦                       09/26 13:27
噓 leftwalk:歧視單身逆                                             09/26 13:27
噓 Sanish:我好像知道為什麼馬英九能選上總統了....                   09/26 13:27
噓 kkman321:那遊民或失業者要課什麼稅                               09/26 13:27
噓 chienk:殺雞取卵                                                 09/26 13:29
噓 toya123:什麼樣的智商想出什麼樣的方法  不意外                    09/26 13:29
→ kkman321:馬英九無能 課個無能稅吧                                09/26 13:29
噓 BloodyBerry:讓我年薪100萬我馬上就找人結婚！                     09/26 13:29
噓 ogcman:你知道你這個方法跟無薪假有異曲同工之妙嗎                 09/26 13:29
噓 darote:我覺得智商太低也要課稅, 因為浪費大家的生命跟勞力         09/26 13:30
噓 maalouf:生小孩只要中出，不需要結婚。單不單身，和生小孩無關。    09/26 13:31
→ toya123:沒有法條可以讓你強徵這種稅 更不合比例原則  想出這種方   09/26 13:31
噓 Benjamin901:想出單身稅的人可以拿諾貝爾獎                        09/26 13:31
→ SuperUp:應該還要加上有多老婆的可退稅~這樣有錢人才能更爽~        09/26 13:31
→ toya123:法  不是智商異於常人  很可能不是地球人                  09/26 13:32
推 ogcman:我想 你應該只知道 飯後喝兩杯清玉 會很舒服                09/26 13:32
噓 soramoe:智障政府 沒錢怎麼結婚 客你娘的稅                        09/26 13:33
噓 ts00690106:..........                                           09/26 13:33
→ BRANFORD:以台灣來講  政府弄成智商過高需課重稅或智商高需人道毀   09/26 13:34
→ BRANFORD:滅  應該更符合現代政府的作為                           09/26 13:34
噓 rofellosx:單身逃離鬼島比較容易                                  09/26 13:34
噓 shay828:課個屁稅                                                09/26 13:37
噓 howard1110:重點在於22K沒錢買房、買車、養小孩 不再加稅           09/26 13:37
噓 ljsnonocat4:開放窮人合法搶劫有錢人...這可能會好一點             09/26 13:37
噓 Refauth:讓我想起了羅馬尼亞在二戰後的悲劇....想死嗎！決策者！！  09/26 13:37
噓 sakula0616:你馬英九嗎 你                                        09/26 13:38
噓 zeroex2100:情感問題拿來當政務  笑死                             09/26 13:38
噓 qq204:直接輔助跟那些高層肥羊薪資一樣的金額 生10個都不是問題     09/26 13:38
噓 foamy:請問課稅的立意在哪？懲罰單身                              09/26 13:39
噓 GPX2000:課三小啦，想出這方法的是智障好嗎?                       09/26 13:40
噓 syk1104:媽的我就不想結婚啦~操                                   09/26 13:40
噓 jimcheer:我覺得腦殘更應該被課稅                                 09/26 13:40
噓 WalkFish:結婚也死不婚也死 再下來你要不要課自殺稅?               09/26 13:40
噓 piggylamb:那乾脆課老人稅好了,解決人口老年化和年金問題           09/26 13:41
噓 e1q3z9c7:幹人民是生育工具膩啦                                   09/26 13:41
噓 OutOfTears:可笑，課廢文稅可能比較有用                           09/26 13:41
→ syk1104:沒錢結婚了~有錢給你課?白痴政府                          09/26 13:41
→ e1q3z9c7:政府貪污無能誰敢生幹                                   09/26 13:41
噓 triptane:你的腦子....還好吧                                     09/26 13:41
噓 PELJE:歧視宅男                                                  09/26 13:41
噓 qq204:你真是吳敦義                                              09/26 13:41
噓 chungkai:全台灣你最聰明   馬英九智商還好比你高                  09/26 13:42
噓 einard666:結婚不過就是一張紙 200塊就有了 馬上就節稅             09/26 13:42
→ syk1104:一.一..原來是你幻想..我以為真的有..好險你沒當官~(擦汗   09/26 13:42
噓 hisashilie:這根本不會有用好嗎?都假結婚就好啦                    09/26 13:42
噓 valenci:養小孩多少錢？多少單身是沒錢的？病弱的？                09/26 13:42
噓 TaTa5566:吃屎                                                   09/26 13:43
→ valenci:生下來全丟給政府養或許就可行了？哈哈不過這樣媽媽還要花  09/26 13:43
噓 bg00004:唉.....                                                 09/26 13:44
噓 gioiechang:現在結婚不生小孩的也很多!!!!                         09/26 13:44
→ crashonU:這要加年齡限制啦 例如:40歲仍單身者 就要繳稅 否則年輕   09/26 13:44
推 urdie:ㄏㄏ 跟政府思維很像喔  根本完全搞不清楚問題點在哪         09/26 13:44
噓 kei29:這是想要法西斯復闢喔                                      09/26 13:44
推 Sayd20:八卦吧什麼時候這麼多甲甲                                 09/26 13:44
→ valenci:十個月懷胎，有沒有補助十個月的生小孩工資？              09/26 13:44
→ crashonU:人一出社會就要繳稅                                     09/26 13:44
→ urdie:如果經濟好 人民富裕 犯罪率低 黑道少  誰不想結婚生子??     09/26 13:45
噓 sr0:科你老木                                                    09/26 13:45
噓 olalo:你怎麼不出錢幫大家養小孩?這樣大家就會多結婚了             09/26 13:45
噓 lineage1231:                                                    09/26 13:45
噓 devilsky:好你X 你自己先去生個10個8個再來說這些屁話還不晚        09/26 13:46
推 nousgu:好像蠻有道理的                                           09/26 13:46
噓 austin69:  你給我錢 我幫你生                                    09/26 13:47
噓 ogcman:你知道台灣負債22兆 生一個出來就要背債80-90萬嗎           09/26 13:47
噓 toya123:前提就有洞了 如果大部分都22K關養自己就有問題了          09/26 13:47
→ valenci:你是想讓稅基爆掉嗎？窮而不結的給你扣30%也抽不到多少     09/26 13:47
噓 EX37:房屋實價課稅才有效，台灣人對房子的依賴感太重了             09/26 13:47
噓 hunter1214:建議政府發行生子卡                                   09/26 13:47
→ ogcman:你知道不是每個人的老爸都是李嘉誠、王永慶嗎               09/26 13:47
噓 jsbegin:單身錯了嗎                                              09/26 13:48
噓 zeta731115:幹 單身招誰惹誰了                                    09/26 13:49
→ toya123:22K養小孩的支出就比那3%還高了  白癡才生                 09/26 13:49
噓 mamaka:Zzz                                                      09/26 13:50
→ valenci:有錢好幾房的生一堆的抽6%，然後子女教育費窮宅稅補？      09/26 13:50
→ toya123:奶粉尿布 的使用量你知道有多驚人嗎  還有小孩的保險       09/26 13:50
噓 ponpondapipi:朝聖噓                                             09/26 13:51
噓 lulocke:你乾脆規定  有CCR的稅0%  這樣不但結婚率不用管           09/26 13:51
→ lulocke:還有一堆無老爸小孩可以給政府衝生育率                    09/26 13:52
→ toya123:還有教育經費 醫療經費  你哪來這麼多錢                   09/26 13:52
噓 chx64:2樓一語道破                                               09/26 13:52
→ toya123:又是一個玩遊戲看世界的                                  09/26 13:53
噓 Luminolio:嘖 離婚率這麼高 要課也是課離婚稅                      09/26 13:53
→ syk1104:CCR-50%稅~30年後台灣遍地金髮碧眼~改造成功!!!            09/26 13:54
噓 a00779928:找不到女人你以為我願意 幹!                            09/26 13:54
噓 Irenicus:所以大家都生一卡車八嘎囧會讓國家很有競爭力就是了       09/26 13:54
噓 euphoria01:養不起是單身欠你的嗎？先檢討為何沒人想生吧！沒小孩   09/26 13:55
→ euphoria01:頂多滅國                                             09/26 13:55
噓 toya123:錯誤的前提還可以得到每人生三個怎麼算的                  09/26 13:56
噓 proprome:世界奇觀出現了                                         09/26 13:57
噓 deerx:一胎補助一間房屋  保證狂生                                09/26 13:58
噓 bluetory99:白痴完全不可行你要不要讀讀財政學看政府的職能是什麼   09/26 13:58
噓 Whitening:單身臭了嗎...這樣宗瑞哥要怎麼出來玩?你有得看嗎?       09/26 13:58
推 urdie:大概以為人生跟線上遊戲一樣 想結婚就結婚 其他都沒想過      09/26 13:58
噓 simga:北七政策~~本末倒置~~                                      09/26 13:58
噓 bingchang:我猜下一步提出~人工製造嬰兒~還可以客製化一步到位= =   09/26 14:00
→ bingchang:還可增加人口~~~啾咪> <                                09/26 14:01
噓 bluesky33:大魯蛇生小魯蛇阿                                      09/26 14:01
噓 qazsugf:你以為我自己想單身嗎？QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ       09/26 14:02
噓 moonshen:你真不簡單 可以得諾貝爾獎                              09/26 14:02
噓 wmf:單身是因為經濟不好。請勿成為政府打手  政府沒錢請振興經濟先  09/26 14:04
噓 vAndaLs:你要是想要展現你的腦容量 你有更好的作法                 09/26 14:05
推 Leeng:還不簡單 找個不想生的掛名配偶就好了                       09/26 14:07
噓 acharles01:再生下去台灣就要爆了 丟搞喔                          09/26 14:09
噓 otaku5566:想結就結喔，是跟PVC還是左右手？                       09/26 14:10
推 rickwu43:板上魯蛇七成沒交過女友 他們也不想啊                    09/26 14:12
噓 xgodtw:真的就是欠噓                                             09/26 14:13
噓 enstai:腦殘                                                     09/26 14:13
→ koy70163:超低能 吃飽太閒發廢文?                                 09/26 14:16
噓 DarkerDuck:課打手槍稅，增加強暴率，你說好不好~~~                09/26 14:17
→ DarkerDuck:沒準備好就結婚生子，根本就跟強暴一樣是造孽           09/26 14:18
→ DarkerDuck:不過你可以去當SOD編劇，這劇情SOD好像還沒演過         09/26 14:19
→ icome:哪個腦殘想出來的                                          09/26 14:20
噓 carasu:又不是共產黨國家還在管人家要不要結婚生小孩,自己生活都夠  09/26 14:21
噓 eqmblcor:白痴....少子化主因是生活開銷大~自己都快養不活了        09/26 14:21
噓 funk167:請不要懲罰還沒出生的小孩好嗎!!                          09/26 14:21
→ carasu:窮了,還要生個小孩來累死自己,也沒好環境給他成長.          09/26 14:22
噓 Ftaro:還好不是你從政                                            09/26 14:22
噓 yhyanzi:爛死                                                    09/26 14:23
推 MacOSX10:如果生下劣質基因應該要加稅才對                         09/26 14:24
噓 ttungg:生了養不起全家都自x ?                                    09/26 14:28
噓 rossikao:你娶左右手回家還想減少課稅?? 你想太多,還是尻太多??     09/26 14:29
噓 lijenc:去旁邊玩沙沙，別發廢文了                                 09/26 14:31
噓 ccucwc:幹你老師的就是沒錢才結不了婚，課你老木的稅啦             09/26 14:32
噓 bomei:課你妹                                                    09/26 14:33
噓 aassddgg:幹 我也不想要單生阿...                                 09/26 14:36
→ laoh:要這樣課, 你要不要乾脆規定要炒房地產先生10個比較快         09/26 14:38
噓 wonderverge:現在這種生活環境…敢強迫大家結婚的政府一定會倒吧    09/26 14:38
→ laoh:不然乾脆施行全民公務員制好了,這樣肯定刺激生育率            09/26 14:39
噓 joliha:老人沒生產力浪費國家糧食 以後70歲以上老人重課老人稅好了  09/26 14:39
→ laoh:然後國家不用幾年就倒了                                     09/26 14:39
噓 exponential7:                                                   09/26 14:39
→ ogcman:扣老人稅 才是最正確的                                    09/26 14:41
噓 bbbruce:...                                                     09/26 14:42
噓 hipark:你可以生10個就不會少子化了                               09/26 14:44

----本文使用PCMAN+BBI轉貼----


※ 新版PCMAN開放測試中，新增功能：    



用PCMAN+BBI連回PTT原文